As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

I Finally Shared My Music – And the Feedback Surprised Me

—

, ,


I have shied away from posting things on the ThinkSpace Education Discord server but a while back I decided to bite the bullet and shared an uplifting composition exercise from the Mastering Orchestral Composition with Spitfire Audio course.

The assignment was to continue a piece of music to create an uplifting mood.

I didn’t expect any comments — but the positive feedback I received boosted my confidence, motivation, and sense of creative direction. Here are the comments that meant the most.

Here is the assignment audio that I posted first

And here are some of the positive comments:

Good stuff !! Melody certainly is uplifting.

I like how you emphasize the transitions between melodies, it’s very good, I’m learning from you.

Very nice, the choice to use the woodwinds for the melody definitely feels light and uplifting. I can imagine this in a period drama in a scene setting section!

I really liked that, very uplifting. It would not be out of place for TV theme like the Antiques Roadshow, or something like that.

Great job! It feels like a strong continuation of the piece — good flow, creative variation, proper mood, and solid sound choices.

I have just finished doing the same challenge! You have taken the braver course of going for a more noticeable change, but you have indeed maintained the uplifting mood. Well done!

They were some very nice comments. What a nice bunch of people.

I was pleased to get such positive feedback. Maybe I should not be so reserved about sharing things anymore.


Discover more from PhysMuse

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

4 responses to “I Finally Shared My Music – And the Feedback Surprised Me”

  1. Sounds splendid! I have found that much of my own reservations about sharing my work are often baseless -not that it cannot be critiqued- but the fear of judgment easily supersedes my desire to share. With this in mind though, it is good to get feedback! Not only is it encouraging, but consistent, growth oriented critique helps more than the lack thereof. I remember this when contemplating whether I should share something or not.

    1. Thank you. I agree that feedback is always good in learning and improving, but it is daunting nonetheless, especially when you perceive other members of the group to be at a higher level. It is definitely encouraging and motivating to receive positive feedback, and constructive criticisms helps one to grow in their craft. Thank you for the comment.

  2. Sometimes it takes just an initiative to realise your work was ready long before you felt you were. Keep sharing, this seems like just the beginning

    1. Thank you for the encouragement. I think you are right. Often we think things are not ready and keep tinkering adding little value, through fear of releasing things to the world. I am much happier about sharing things now. Thank you for your kind words.

Leave a Reply

● About Me

I’m Julian — composer‑educator and the creator of PhysMuse. I share my journey through music engraving, theory, and creative study, building clear, beautiful resources for musicians and learners. This blog is where I document the process, the experiments, and the things I’m learning along the way.